After well over five hours spent listening to county residents debate the merits of weighing in on the handling of the Israel-Hamas war, Allegheny County Council voted Tuesday against a resolution urging the federal government to push for a cease-fire.

A total of 279 people signed up to speak at the meeting, although dozens did not show or needed to leave before their turn came. According to a rough count, about 137 county residents spoke in support of the resolution, and 70 spoke against it.

In the end, council members voted 9-3 to oppose the resolution, with two members abstaining.

Bethany Hallam, Dan Grzybek and Anita Prizio, all co-sponsors of the resolution, voted in support.

Advertise with us

Council members Jack Betkowski, Sam DeMarco, Suzanne Filiaggi, Nicholas Futules, Patrick Catena, Paul Klein, Bob Macey, John Palmiere and Robert Palmosina voted no.

Council members David Bonaroti and Michelle Naccarati-Chapkis abstained. DeWitt Walton was absent.

Specifically, the resolution called on President Joe Biden’s administration to:

• “Immediately call for and facilitate de-escalation and a cease-fire to urgently end the current violence.”

• “Immediately call for and facilitate a release of all hostages held in Palestine and Israel.”

Advertise with us

• “Promptly send and facilitate the entry of humanitarian assistance, at the scale needed, into Gaza.”

The debate dominated Tuesday’s meeting, although council also spent some time discussing a bill about the responsibilities of the county’s chief assessment officer, before referring the legislation to a committee for further review.

But most of the meeting was spent hearing views on the resolution tied to the war.

The conflict in Gaza has sparked protests and debates across the country, including in Pittsburgh. The presidential primaries have seen protest votes meant to send messages to the candidates about U.S. involvement, while members of Congress have been criticized for their stances or affiliations.

At the Allegheny County Council meeting Tuesday, supporters of the proposed resolution said not taking action would amount to the council supporting Israel continuing to conduct a genocide in Gaza. They noted that council supported a resolution in October condemning the attack by Hamas on Israel on Oct. 7 but had delayed acting on calling for a cease-fire for several months while Israel has continued to bomb Gaza.

Advertise with us

Those who spoke against the resolution said it wouldn’t do anything to end the violence, and that it would further spark division and antisemitism in the Pittsburgh region. They also said it would be a signal that council supports Hamas, a terrorist group that does not support a permanent cease-fire.

As some council members were explaining their votes, audience members started criticizing them for opposing the resolution. A few people were kicked out of the meeting after repeated warnings from Mr. Catena to calm down.

Even after the meeting was adjourned, it took some time for attendees to exit, as a majority in support of the resolution chanted “Cease-fire now!” and “Free Palestine!” The room was cleared without further incident.

Meanwhile, council members agreed to refer the chief assessment officer bill to the council’s Special Committee on Assessment Practices. Mr. Catena is the lead sponsor.

Mr. Catena held the bill from a council meeting last month, and said during a break during Tuesday’s meeting that there were still “technical aspects” that needed to be fixed.

Advertise with us

He added that he still needed to confer with Councilwoman Suzanne Filiaggi, the chair of the committee. He believes council should have more oversight on the position, but also that there are aspects of county code that aren’t enforced in practice or are outdated.

Mr. Catena’s bill, as currently drafted, changes the process for how the chief assessment officer, a key position in handling property assessments countywide, is appointed.

Currently, the person is appointed by the county manager with the unanimous consent of the Property Assessment Oversight Board. That board no longer exists, he said.

The bill states that position would now be appointed by a majority vote of County Council members.

The legislation also requires the officer to provide quarterly reports on the Office of Property Assessments, including information related to “assessment roll correction, assessment roll certification, calculations and data gathering relating to the common level ratio and other statistical factors relevant to the assessment system, new property assessments” and other relevant information.

Advertise with us

Property assessments have been a hot topic in the county and were an issue in last year’s county executive race.

Steve Bohnel: sbohnel@post-gazette.com